Imagine raising $1,108, learning about your supporters, spreading awareness, and gaining new followers—all in just one week, with no ad spend. That’s exactly what one nonprofit achieved in February 2025 with a small campaign targeting 799 subscribers. The result? A 40% conversion rate, 15 fundraisers averaging $73.87 each, and zero dollars spent on ads. This wasn’t a one-off—it’s a repeatable blueprint for nonprofit fundraising success.

The secret weapon behind this win? Social direct messaging, powered by GoodUnited, the #1 platform for nonprofits looking to connect with supporters in a personal, immediate way. Let’s break down the data, uncover why this campaign soared, and show how your nonprofit can turn small efforts into monumental victories.

‍

The Data Behind the Success

‍

Launched on February 3, 2025, and concluding by February 28, this revenue-driven campaign tied into a cause-specific awareness month. Here’s a look at the key metrics:

• Subscribers Targeted: 799
• Messages Delivered: 656 (82.10% delivery rate)
• Messages Opened: 564 (85.98% open rate)
• Clicks: 88 (15.60% click rate)
• Fundraisers Created: 15
• Conversion Rate: 40.54% (of those who clicked, 37 said “I’m In!”)
• Total Raised: $1,108
• Average Fundraiser Amount: $73.87
• Revenue per Subscriber Delivered: $1.69

Contrast this with a larger campaign from the same period—like one targeting 112,965 subscribers and raising $1,982 with a 2.27% conversion rate—and it’s clear: bigger isn’t always better. This small campaign’s precision and connection made all the difference.

‍

Why Social Direct Messaging Delivered a 40% Conversion Rate

‍

What drove this standout 40.54% conversion rate? The answer lies in social direct messaging, a channel where GoodUnited reigns as the #1 platform for nonprofits. Here’s why it worked—and why it’s a game-changer:

‍

1. Personalization at Scale

Rather than a generic appeal, the campaign invited supporters to “start fundraisers and share their personal connection to the cause.” Social direct messaging didn’t just broadcast this—it delivered it straight to supporters’ Messenger inboxes, creating an intimate, one-on-one vibe. The result? An 85.98% open rate, blowing past typical email open rates of 20-30%. GoodUnited’s platform made every subscriber feel seen, not just reached.

2. Urgency and Relevance

Tied to an awareness month, the campaign hit at a peak moment of supporter interest. Social direct messaging excels in real-time engagement, and GoodUnited ensured the message landed when it mattered most. This timeliness sparked a 15.60% click rate, as supporters responded to a cause already on their minds. The platform’s ability to ride social media waves turned relevance into action.

3. Frictionless Action

GoodUnited’s seamless integration with Facebook fundraisers made participation a breeze. One click took supporters to a pre-populated fundraiser page—no hoops, no hassle. This simplicity fueled the leap from clicks to conversions, with 40.54% of clickers starting a fundraiser. Compare that to a similar campaign’s 3.62% conversion rate—GoodUnited’s streamlined process cut through the clutter.

4. Emotional Resonance

The campaign’s focus on personal stories struck a chord, amplified by social direct messaging’s conversational tone. When 37 supporters clicked “I’m In!” out of 88, they weren’t just giving—they were joining a movement. GoodUnited fosters this intimacy, turning digital outreach into a heartfelt call. The $73.87 average per fundraiser shows how deeply supporters connected, giving generously because they cared.

‍

Lessons for Other Nonprofits

‍

This campaign’s success isn’t a fluke—it’s a roadmap. Here’s how your nonprofit can replicate it with GoodUnited’s social direct messaging:

‍

1. Start Small, Think Big

You don’t need a sprawling subscriber list to make waves. With just 799 subscribers, this campaign raised $1,108—proof that targeting a passionate core trumps chasing numbers. Use GoodUnited to pinpoint your most engaged supporters (think past donors or event attendees) and craft a message that resonates with them.

2. Tap Into Timely Moments

Link your campaign to a relevant milestone, like an awareness month or a matching gift deadline. The data shows February campaigns—like this one or another with a 74.11% open rate—thrive when timed right. GoodUnited’s real-time delivery ensures your message hits when supporters are ready to act.

3. Make It Personal

Invite supporters to share their “why.” GoodUnited’s platform lets you tailor messages and track responses (e.g., 37 “I’m In!” vs. 51 “Not right now”), building a feedback loop to refine your approach while forging stronger ties. Personal connection was key to this campaign’s 40% conversion rate.

4. Simplify the Ask

High conversions depend on low barriers. GoodUnited’s social fundraising integrations—like the link that drove this campaign’s 15 fundraisers—make action instant. Pair that with a clear CTA (“Start a fundraiser now!”), and you’ll see clicks turn into results.

5. Measure and Iterate

The $1.69 revenue per subscriber delivered offers a treasure trove of insight. GoodUnited’s analytics—delivery, opens, clicks, conversions—let you pinpoint what works. This campaign’s 15.60% click rate doubled the dataset’s 7.3% average, showing the power of testing and tweaking.

‍

GoodUnited: Your Partner in Big Wins

‍

Why does social direct messaging shine? It meets supporters where they are—on social platforms, ready to engage. GoodUnited, the #1 social direct messaging platform, empowers nonprofits to break through the noise of emails and ads with personalized, urgent, and actionable outreach. This campaign’s 40% conversion rate towers over the 2-5% norm of other channels, and it’s just one example of GoodUnited’s impact.

Look at another effort from January 31, 2025, raising $3,795 with a 3.62% conversion rate, or a February 26, 2025, campaign with a 6.63% click rate—both powered by GoodUnited. Whether you’re driving revenue or rallying a community, this platform delivers.

‍

Inspiration for the Road Ahead

‍

This story is more than stats—it’s a testament to what happens when passion meets the right tools. With GoodUnited, a small team turned 799 subscribers into $1,108 of impact, one personal story at a time. Picture what your nonprofit could achieve: transforming a few clicks into a flood of support, uniting your community around your mission, and proving that even the smallest campaigns can spark monumental change.

‍

Ready to make your next campaign a big win? Start with GoodUnited—because in 2025, the smallest messages are driving the greatest impact.

‍